Tag: LIPs

Did Precambrian BIFs ‘fall’ into the mantle to trigger mantle plumes?

Published on by zooks7772 Comments

How the Earth has been shaped has depended to a large extent on a very simple variable among rocks: their density. Contrasts in density between vast rock masses are expressed when gravity attempts to maintain a balance of forces. The abrupt difference in elevation of the solid surface at the boundaries of oceans and continents – the Earth’s hypsometry – stems from the contrasted densities of continental and oceanic crust: the one dominated by granitic rocks (~2.8 t m-3) the other by those of basaltic composition (~ 3.0 t m-3). Astronomers have estimated that Earth’s overall density is about 5.5 t m-3 – it is the densest planet in the Solar System. The underlying mantle makes up 68% of Earth’s mass, with a density that increases with depth from 3.3 to 5.4 t m-3 in a stepwise fashion, at a number of discontinuities, because mantle minerals undergo changes induced by pressure. The remaining one third of Earth’s mass resides in the iron-nickel core at densities between 9.5 to 14.5 t m-3. Such density layering is by no means completely stable. Locally increased temperatures in mantle rocks reduce their density sufficiently for masses to rise convectively to be replaced by cooler ones, albeit slowly. By far the most important form of convection affecting the lithosphere involves the resorption of oceanic lithosphere plates at destructive margins, which results in subduction. This is thought to be due to old, cold oceanic basalts undergoing metamorphism as pressure increases during subduction. They are transformed at depth to a mineral assemblage (eclogite) that is denser (3.4 to 3.5 t m-3) than the enveloping upper mantle. That density contrast is sufficient for gravity to pull slabs of oceanic lithosphere downwards. This slab-pull force is transmitted through oceanic lithosphere that remains at the surface to become the dominant driver of modern plate tectonics. As a result, extension of the surface oceanic lithosphere at constructive margins draws mantle upwards to partially melt at reduced pressure, thus adding new basaltic crust at mid-ocean rift systems to maintain a form of mantle convection. Seismic tomography shows that active subducted slabs become ductile about 660 km beneath the surface and below that no earthquakes are detected. Quite possibly, the density of the reconstituted lithospheric slab becomes less than that of the mantle below the 660 km discontinuity. So the subducted slab continues by moving sideways and buckling in response to the ‘push’ from its rigid upper parts above. But it has been suggested that some subducted slabs do finally sink to the core-mantle boundary, but that is somewhat conjectural.

Typical banded iron formation

There are sedimentary rocks whose density at the surface exceeds that of the upper mantle: banded iron formations (BIFs) that contain up to 60% iron oxides (mainly Fe2O3) and have an average density at the surface of around 3.5 t m-3. BIFs formed mainly in the late Archaean and early Proterozoic Eons  (3.2 to 1.0 Ga) and none are known from the last 400 Ma. They formed when soluble iron-2 (Fe2+) – being added to ocean water by submarine hydrothermal activity –was precipitated as Fe3+ in the form of iron oxide (Fe2O3) where oxygen was present in ocean water. With little doubt this happened only in shallow marine basins where cyanobacteria that appeared about 3.5 Ga ago had sufficient sunlight to photosynthesise. Until about 2.4 Ga the atmosphere and thus the bulk of ocean water contained very little oxygen so the oceans were pervaded by soluble iron so that BIFs were able to form wherever such biological activity was going on. Conceivably (but not proven), that BIF-forming biochemical reaction may even have operated far from land in ocean surface water, slowly to deposit Fe2O3 on the deep ocean floor. After 2.4 Ga oxygen began to build in the atmosphere after the Great Oxidation Event had begon. That time was also when the greatest production of BIFs took place. Strangely, the amount of BIF in the geological record fell during the next 600 Ma to rise again to a very high peak at 1.8 Ga. Since there must have been sufficient soluble iron and an increasing amount of available oxygen for BIFs to form throughout that ‘lean’ period the drop in BIF formation is paradoxical. After 1.0 Ga BIFs more or less disappear. By then so much oxygen was present in the atmosphere and from top to bottom in ocean water that soluble iron was mostly precipitated at its hydrothermal source on the ocean floor. Incidentally, modern ocean surface water far from land contains so little dissolved iron that little microbiological activity goes on there: iron is an essential nutrient so the surface waters of remote oceans are effectively ‘wet deserts’.

Plots of probability of LIPs and BIFs forming at the Earth’s surface during Precambrian times, based on actual occurrences (Credit: Keller, et al., modified Fig 1A)

Spurred by the fact that if a sea-floor slab dominated by BIFs was subducted it wouldn’t need eclogite formation to sink into the mantle, Duncan Keller of Rice University in Texas and other US and Canadian colleagues have published a ‘thought experiment’ using time-series data on LIPs and BIFs compiled by other geoscientists (Keller, D.S. et al. 2023. Links between large igneous province volcanism and subducted iron formations. Nature Geoscience, v. 16, article; DOI: 10.1038/s41561-023-01188-1.). Their approach involves comparing the occurrences of 54 BIFs through time with signs of activity in the mantle during the Palaeo- and Mesoproterozoic Eras, as marked by large igneous provinces (LIPs) during that time span. To do this they calculated the degree of correlation in time between BIFs and LIPs. The authors chose a minimum area for LIPs of 400 thousand km2 – giving a total of 66 well-dated examples. Because the bulk of Precambrian flood-basalt provinces, such as occurred during the Phanerozoic, have been eroded away, most of their examples are huge, well-dated dyke swarms that almost certainly fed such plateau basalts. Rather than a direct time-correlation, what emerged was a match-up that covered 74% of the LIPs with BIFs that had formed about 241 Ma earlier. They also found a less precise correlation between LIPs associated with 241 Ma older BIFs and protracted periods of stable geomagnetic field, known as ‘superchrons’. These are thought by geophysicists to be influenced by heat flow through the core-mantle boundary (CMB).

The high bulk density of BIFs at the surface would be likely to remain about 15 % greater than that of peridotite as pressure increased with depth in the mantle. Such slabs could therefore penetrate the 660 mantle discontinuity. Their subduction would probably result in their eventually ‘piling up’ in the vicinity of the CMB. The high iron content of BIFs may also have changed the way that the core loses heat, thereby triggering mantle plumes. Certainly, there is a complex zone of ultra-low seismic velocities (ULVZ) that signifies hot, ductile material extending above the CMB. Because BIFs’ high iron-content makes them thermally highly conductive compared with basalts and other sediments, they may be responsible. Clearly, Keller et al’s hypothesis is likely to be controversial and they hope that other geoscientists will test it with new or re-analysed geophysical data. But the possibility of BIFs falling to the base of the mantle spectacularly extends the influence of surface biological processes to the entire planet. And, indeed, it may have shaped the later part of its tectonic history having changed the composition of the deep mantle. The interconnectedness of the Earth system also demands that the consequences – plumes and large igneous provinces – would have fed back to the Precambrian biosphere. See also: Iron-rich rocks unlock new insights into Earth’s planetary history, Science Daily, 2 June 2023

The late-Ordovician mass extinction: volcanic connections

Published on by zooks7771 Comment

The dominant feature of Phanerozoic stratigraphy is surely the way that many of the formally named major time boundaries in the Stratigraphic Column coincide with sudden shifts in the abundance and diversity of fossil organisms. That is hardly surprising since all the globally recognised boundaries between Eras, Periods and lesser divisions in relative time were, and remain, based on palaeontology. Two boundaries between Eras – the Palaeozoic-Mesozoic (Permian-Triassic) at 252 Ma and Mesozoic-Cenozoic (Cretaceous-Palaeogene) at 66 Ma – and a boundary between Periods – Triassic-Jurassic at 201 Ma – coincide with enormous declines in biological diversity. They are defined by mass extinctions involving the loss of up to 95 % of all species living immediately before the events. Two other extinction events that match up to such awesome statistics do not define commensurately important stratigraphic boundaries. The Frasnian Stage of the late-Devonian closed at 372 Ma with a prolonged series of extinctions (~20 Ma) that eliminated  at least 70% of all species that were alive before it happened. The last 10 Ma of the Ordovician period witnessed two extinction events that snuffed out about the same number of species. The Cambrian Period is marked by 3 separate events that in percentage terms look even more extreme than those at the end of the Ordovician, but there are a great many less genera known from Cambrian times than formed fossils during the Ordovician.

Untitled-1
Faunal extinctions during the Phanerozoic in relation to the Stratigraphic Column.

Empirical coincidences between the precise timing of several mass extinctions with that of large igneous events – mainly flood basalts – suggest a repeated volcanic connection with deterioration of conditions for life. That is the case for four of the Famous Five, the end-Ordovician die-off having been ascribed to other causes; global cooling that resulted in south-polar glaciation of the Gondwana supercontinent and/or an extra-solar gamma-ray burst (predicated on the preferential extinction of Ordovician near-surface, planktonic fauna such as some trilobite families). Neither explanation is entirely satisfactory, but new evidence has emerged that may support a volcanic trigger (Jones, D.S. et al. 2017. A volcanic trigger for the Late Ordovician mass extinction? Mercury data from south China and Laurentia. Geology, v. 45, p. 631-634; doi:10.1130/G38940.1). David Jones and his US-Japan colleagues base their hypothesis on several very strong mercury concentrations in thin sequences in the western US and southern China of late Ordovician marine sediments that precede, but do not exactly coincide with, extinction pulses. They ascribe these to large igneous events that had global effects, on the basis of similar Hg anomalies associated with extinction-related LIPs. Yet no such volcanic provinces have been recorded from that time-range of the Ordovician, although rift-related volcanism of roughly that age has been reported from Korea. That does not rule out the possibility as LIPs, such as the Ontong Java Plateau, are known from parts of the modern ocean floor that formed in the Mesozoic and Cenozoic. Ordovician ocean floor was subducted long ago.

The earlier Hg pulses coincide with evidence for late Ordovician glaciations over what is now Africa and eastern South America. The authors suggest that massive volcanism may then have increased the Earth’s albedo by blasting sulfates into the stratosphere. A similar effect may have resulted from chemical weathering of widely exposed flood basalts which draws down atmospheric CO2. The later pulses coincide with the end of Gondwanan glaciation, which may signify massive emanation of volcanic CO2 into the atmosphere and global warming. Despite being somewhat speculative, in the absence of evidence, a common link between the Big Five plus several other major extinctions and LIP volcanism would quieten their popular association with major asteroid and/or comet impacts currently being reinvigorated by drilling results from the K-Pg Chicxulub crater offshore of Mexico’s Yucatan Peninsula.

Related articles

Mass extinctions’ connections with volcanism: more support

Published on by zooks7771 Comment

Plot the times of peaks in the rates of extinction during the Mesozoic against those of flood basalt outpourings closest in time to the die-offs and a straight line can be plotted through the data. There is sufficiently low deviation between it and the points that any statistician would agree that the degree of fit is very good. Many geoscientists have used this empirical relationship to claim that all Mesozoic mass extinctions, including the three largest (end-Permian, end-Triassic and end-Cretaceous) were caused in some way by massive basaltic volcanism. The fact that the points are almost evenly spaced – roughly every 30 Ma, except for a few gaps – has suggested to some that there is some kind of rhythm connecting the two very different kinds of event.

Major extinctions and flood basalt events during the Mesozoic (credit: S Drury)
Major Mesozoic extinctions and flood basalt events (credit: S Drury)

Leaving aside that beguiling periodicity, the hypothesis of a flood-basalt – extinction link has a major weakness. The only likely intermediary is atmospheric, through its composition and/or climate; flood volcanism was probably not violent. Both probably settle down quickly in geological terms. Moreover, flood basalt volcanism is generally short-lived (a few Ma at most) and seems not to be continuous, unlike that at plate margins which is always going on at one or other place. The great basalt piles of Siberia, around the Central Atlantic margins and in Western India are made up of individual thick and extensive flows separated by fossil soils or boles. This suggests that magma blurted out only occasionally, and was separated by long periods of normality; say between 10 and 100 thousand years. Evidence for the duration of major accelerations, either from stratigraphy and palaeontology or from proxies such as peaks and troughs in the isotopic composition of carbon (e.g. EPN Ni life and mass extinction) is that they too occurred swiftly; in a matter of tens of thousand years. Most of the points on the flood-basalt – extinction plot are too imprecise in the time dimension to satisfy a definite relationship. Opinion has swung behind an instantaneous impact hypothesis for the K-P boundary event rather than one involving the Deccan Traps in India, simply because the best dating of the Deccan suggests extinction seems to have occurred when no flows were being erupted, while the thin impact-related layer in sediments the world over is exactly at the point dividing Cretaceous flora and fauna from those of the succeeding Palaeogene.

Yet no such link to an extraterrestrial factor is known to exist for any other major extinctions, so volcanism seems to be ‘the only game in town’ for the rest. Until basalt dating is universally more precise than it has been up to the present the case is ‘not proven’; but, in the manner of the Scottish criminal law, each is a ‘cold case’ which can be reopened. The previous article  hardens the evidence for a volcanic driver behind the greatest known extinction at the end of the Permian Period. And in short-order, another of the Big Five seems to have been resolved in the same way. A flood basalt province covering a large area of west and north-west Australia (known as the Kalkarindji large igneous province)has long been known to be of roughly Cambrian age but does it tie in with the earliest Phanerozoic mass extinction at the Lower to Middle Cambrian boundary? New age data suggests that it does at the level of a few hundred thousand years (Jourdan, F. et al. 2014. High-precision dating of the Kalkarindji large igneous province, Australia, and synchrony with the Early-Middle Cambrian (Stage 4-5) extinction. Geology, v. 42, p. 543-546). The Kalkarindji basalts have high sulfur contents and are also associated with widespread breccias that suggest that some of the volcanism was sufficiently explosive to have blasted sulfur-oxygen gases into the stratosphere; a known means of causing rapid and massive climatic cooling as well as increasing oceanic acidity. The magma also passed through late Precambrian sedimentary basins which contain abundant organic-rich shales that later sourced extensive petroleum fields. Their thermal metamorphism could have vented massive amounts of CO2 and methane to result in climatic warming. It may have been volcanically-driven climatic chaos that resulted in the demise of much of the earliest tangible marine fauna on Earth to create also a sudden fall in the oxygen content of the Cambrian ocean basins.