Month: May 2009

The ancestral animal

Published on by zooks777Leave a comment

The Cambrian Explosion of shell-bearing animals and the preceding, diverse and very odd Ediacaran fauna that left imprints and moulds in the Late Neoproterozoic both posed two puzzles for early palaeontologists. What organisms evolved so that unmistakable traces of animal life were able to leave fossils after about 600 Ma, and what pace did evolution take to present us with virtually all the animal phyla, including some not around nowadays, ‘fully separated’? Molecular genetic studies of living animals are beginning to throw up some answers (Holmes, R. 2009. The mother of us all. New Scientist, v. 202 (2 May Issue), p. 38-41). It is a complex and growing field, so Bob Holmes’ review of current ideas on the last common ancestor of the animals is welcome for non-specialists. It does look as though the radiation was long before the Ediacaran, but may well have been very rapid. The genetically closest single-celled organism to metazoan animals are the rare choanoflagellates; filter feeders with a collar-like structure and a tail. They bear some resemblance to the feeding cells of sponges, but sponges in their current form seem highly unlikely as the Ur-creature, totally lacking any organs and really just a coexistence of clone-like cells. Gene sequencing from 42 animal groups puts sponges at the bottom of a relatedness tree, yet at the bottom of two of the main branches. So the sponges do indeed seem to have it as our ultimate ancestors. Yet the flurry of ever-more detailed sequencing, for more and more groups using increasingly sophisticated statistical analysis has fired up controversy. Jellyfish-like ctenophores now have a look-in too, as do mysterious placozoans, according to one or other researcher. This field is throwing up an object lesson for hubristic scientists used to counting their chickens… No, the votes are never all in, and surprises always lie ahead for both the unwary and the patient. 

Luckily, Holmes closes by looking at a careful proposal for the ‘How’. Claus Nielson of the University of Copenhagen, a major ‘player’ in this field, has suggested how starting with a slab-like choanoflagellate, with all its function cells on the outside, might have evolved be curling to enclose a tube of inward facing cells; a precursor of a gut. One next step from there could be specialisation of some cells as nerves, then the development of a ‘mouth’ and ‘anus’ – the basis for the bilateral symmetry of all higher animals including ourselves. As for the ‘When’, there are sufficient leads from a molecular clock approach to settle on the oddest climatic events of the last 1.5 Ga of the Proterozoic, the near global glaciations or ‘Snowball Earth’ events that began around 750 Ma ago.

Photosynthesis from way back when: the hunt for RuBisCO

Charles Darwin had an abiding fascination with plants, though one that was essentially practical through observation and breeding. That is sufficient excuse in his bicentenary for reviews, but a good way to honour his legacy is again to push essays to the leading edge of present understanding (Leslie, M. 2009. On the origin of photosynthesis. Science, v. 323, p. 1286-1287). Being able to convert sunlight, water and carbon dioxide to the basis of their own life and that of the rest of the planet, plants and other photosynthesising organisms are the fundamental essence of the living world. Land plants are recent developments, emerging in the Silurian around 425 Ma ago with presumed terrestrial spores some 50 Ma earlier. Their forbears were almost certainly marine algae. Yet they are highly evolved, and it is not to separate precursors that palaeobotanists can look  for origins, but to the internal chloroplasts that look remarkable like cells in their own right with separate DNA and RNA. They perform the astonishing trick of breaking the extremely strong OH-H bonds that form the water molecule otherwise achieved either by extremely high temperatures or by electrolysis. The trick is for an organism to grab an electron thereby releasing the bond and both hydrogen and oxygen. The hydrogen links to carbon and oxygen from CO2, and the other oxygen is freed. Similar to a magician’s trick with smoke and mirrors, photosynthesis uses pigments. Colour in any object or material results from photons of one wavelength range in sunlight being absorbed so that those reflected make up the colour. The most familiar is chlorophyll which absorbs two wavelength ranges: the red and the blue regions to leave green to be reflected for us to see. It is actually a bit of quantum mechanics, as the absorbed photons carry the energy needed to stoke up that of electrons so that they can break free of the OH-H bond in water and split the molecule. The chain of organic chemistry which follows this trick is hugely complex, and it seems to have taken several forms reflected in specific genes in a growing array of photosynthesising bacteria of various genetic antiquities. There are green ones, blue ones, the reds, yellows and oranges.

Luckily the chemical remnants of photosynthesising bacteria are pretty robust, and also distinctive. The central one for most photosynthesising organisms is an enzyme that is complicated, called Ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase, or RuBisCO for short. Euan Nisbet of Royal Holloway, University of London has been hunting RuBisCO for most of the latter part of his career as a Precambrian geologist. he and colleagues found relics of it in 2.7 Ga Archaean sediments from Zimbabwe and Canada (Nisbet, E.G. et al. 2007. The age of Rubisco: the evolution of oxygenic photosynthesis. Geobiology, v. 5, p. 311-335) and claim there are signs far older. Needless to say.

A fluffy grazing dinosaur

The Cretaceous of NE China is becoming a favoured destination for palaeobiologists interested in well-preserved vertebrates, little dinosaurs, especially. An increasing number turned up by fossil hunters have skin relics covered in feathers, although they are rarely if at all equipped for flight, are. Recently, something even more bizarre was unearthed (Zheng, X.-T. et al. 2009. An Early Cretaceous heterodontosaurid dinosaur with filamentous integumentary structures. Nature, v. 458, p. 333-336). In plain-speak, Tianyulong confuciusi was fluffy. And as readers really ought to know, the heterodontosaurs were largely Jurassic herbivorous creatures, 70 Ma older than T. confuciusi; a good example of a ‘living fossil’ in its own time. They evolved to large Cretaceous herbivores, such as the famous duck-billed hadrosaurs, Triceratops and Stegosaurus, members of the Ornithischia as opposed to the more commonly carnivorous Saurischia. It was the latter that were widely believed to have been evolutionary branch from which birds sprang. There is a complex argument surrounding T. Confucius, based on which is a proposal that the ancestral dinosaurs were themselves fluffy. First, thoughts of brightly coloured ‘monsters’ and now the possibility that some may even have looked cuddly.

See also: Witmer, L.M. 2009. Fuzzy origins for feathers. Nature, v. 458, p. 293-295.

The swaddled mantle

Published on by zooks777Leave a comment

A great deal of both theoretical petrology and tectonics hinges on how temperature changes with depth within the Earth. The geotherm, as this variation is termed, depends on how heat is conducted – by conduction, convection or radiation – and where it is produced – either as a relic of original heat of Earth’s accretion or through decay of radioactive isotopes. There are plenty of imponderables, and it would be safe to say that, below the depths at which we can measure temperature (a few km), geotherms are guesswork. Metamorphism, partial melting in crust and mantle, and the rigidity of rock depend on temperature and pressure. Rocks that are too cool to act in a plastic manner tend only to conduct heat, and they are poor conductors. This applies to most of the crust, especially the lower continental crust, which is also low in heat producing radioactive K, U and Th isotopes and rigid. The upshot of this is that the crust acts to insulate the mantle, and that implies build-up of heat and temperature just below the crust. A new means of measuring a rock’s thermal conductivity has revealed that thermal conductivity actually decreases as temperature rises (Whittington, A.G et al. 2009. Temperature dependent thermal diffusivity of the Earth’s crust and implications for magmatism. Nature, v. 458, p. 319-321). The range of crustal temperatures in both continental and oceanic crust roughly halves conduction in the lower crust from previously measured values. This further increases insulation of the mantle, boosting the chances of partial melting.

This tallies with a coincidentally published account of how seismic shear waves change speed with depth beneath the oceanic crust (Kawakatsu, H. et al. 2009. Seismic evidence for sharp lithosphere-asthenosphere boundaries of oceanic plates. Science, v. 324, p. 499-502). As well as sharply showing up the lithosphere-asthenosphere boundary, thought to be a transition from brittle to ductile behaviour, it detects thin layers of partially melted peridotite, which facilitates plate tectonics. A further coincidence is publication of an analysis of 15 years of global earthquake records that focuses on the base of the lithosphere (Rychert, C.A. & Shearer, P.M 2009. A global view of the lithosphere-asthenosphere boundary. Science, v. 324, p. 495-498). As well as its thickness this effectively maps the top of the asthenosphere and therefore the thickness of tectonic plates across the planet, albeit crudely (previously both had been estimated from surface heat flow and theoretical models). Beneath cratons that have remained sluggish for more than a billion years, the asthenosphere is deep (~95 km) and thin, shallowing and thickening appreciably beneath more recently active continental belts. Despite being the uppermost Earth and the stuff of plates and the medium upon which they move, respectively, the lithosphere and asthenosphere are less-well known than the mantle and even the core in terms of the mechanical properties. That may sound odd, but there is a good reason why it is so: more deeply travelled seismic waves are a great deal easier to record by the global network of seismic stations than are shallow regions.

On the edge of chaos in the Younger Dryas

Published on by zooks777Leave a comment

Around 13 thousand years ago, the world was warming rapidly and the great northern ice sheets in retreat. Plants, animals and humans in Europe were able to and did migrate northwards. Sea level still being low, there was nothing to stop decolonisation of Britain by crossing the huge fluviatile plain of Doggerland where the southern North Sea now stands.(see Return to ‘Doggerland’ in September 2008 issue of EPN). At 12.9 ka there came the shock of a rapid temperature fall at the start of the Younger Dryas episode, when ice sheets began to re-establish themselves in the upland areas of Britain and Scandinavia. What happened to those intrepid migrants we may never know, but what they would have faced had they chosen to remain in the game-teeming NW Europe of that episode has become clearer with detailed investigations in sediments at the bottom of a Norwegian lake supplied by melt water from glaciers (Bakke, J. et al. 2009. Rapid oceanic and atmospheric changes during the Younger Dryas cold period. Nature Geoscience, v. 2, p. 202-205).

The research by Norwegian and German scientists used two interesting proxies for glacial advance and retreat: the amount of sedimentary titanium and the density of the sediment, both of which would have varied with the rate of glacial erosion. The data were calibrated to time by 96 14C dates, and the sampling frequency (every 0.06 mm for Ti and 5 mm for density through a 1.4m core that represents 1700 years) was sufficient potentially to resolve events to a few days and 6 months respectively. Allowing for background ‘noise’ effects, certainly monthly and annual changes should show up, and indeed they do. The pattern is one of rapidly changing conditions between warm and frigid, which the authors interpret as a result of repeated ‘boom and bust’. At 12.18 ka, further cooling occurred and the late Younger Dryas is the more chaotic part of the record. The hypothesis is that the fluctuations reflect growth and shrinkage of sea ice in the North Atlantic, matched by growth and melting of glaciers. Brief warming during periods of prevailing westerly winds melted glaciers, but fed vast amounts of fresh water to the North Atlantic that in turn encouraged surface waters to freeze. Sea-ice formation and the build-up of a polar high pressure area drove weather systems conducive to westerlies southwards, when glaciers grew. Something suddenly stopped this chaotic behaviour and high latitudes rapidly emerged from frigidity at 11.7 ka: the Holocene had begun and, soon, so would humanity in an equally chaotic manner.

 

Climate at the Eocene-Oligocene (E-O) boundary

Oxygen isotopes from benthic foraminifera in deep-sea sediment cores show an abrupt increase in δ18O at around 34 Ma, which spanned a mere 300 ka. This is taken to indicate withdrawal of ocean water to polar ice caps on land that diamictites from high southern latitudes link to the beginning of glaciation of Antarctic. Then as now, the south polar region was thermally isolated, probably as a result of its having become surrounded by seaways and development of the Antarctic Circumpolar Current from the Palaeocene onwards as a result of the final break-up of Gondwana when it became separated from Australia and South America. Other factors at the E-O boundary seem to have been decreasing atmospheric CO2 and low solar heating as a result of the Milankovich effect. Cooling due to such factors was disrupted and delayed by the spectacular global warming at the Palaeocene-Eocene boundary (55.8 Ma) as a result of massive methane release to the atmosphere. Detailed proxy records from both high- and low-latitude sea-floor sediment cores now resolve fine detail of the shifts in sea-surface temperature (SST) at the E-O boundary (Liu, Z.  et al. 2009. Global cooling during the Eocene-Oligocene climate transition. Science, v. 323, p. 1187-1190). The most profound shift in SST took place at high latitudes (in both Northern and Southern Hemispheres) with a drop of around 5 to 9ºC between 34 to 33.5 Ma. This was followed by slight rise to about 3ºC below pre-E-O conditions. Surprisingly, data from low latitudes ‘flat-lined’ at around 28ºC across the transition, suggesting steady evaporation of seawater, more of which would have precipitated as snow at high latitudes. The ‘hothouse’ conditions of the Cretaceous and early Cenozoic saw estimated high-latitude sea-surface temperatures rise from about 7ºC to 12ºC by the Early Eocene. The protracted global cooling that followed reached about 7ºC by about 42 Ma, which stabilised until 40 Ma when SST fell to about 4ºC just before the E-O boundary (see http://www.learner.org/courses/envsci/visual/visual.php?shortname=cenozoic).

The sudden start of Antarctic glaciation at 34 Ma looks increasing like an example of a chaos-like ‘flip’ in global climatic conditions brought on by a blend of factors that collectively reached a threshold, which once crossed permitted no escape, at least not over the last 30 Ma or so (Kump, L.R. 2009. Tipping pointedly colder. Science, v. 323, p. 1175-1176). That is a point that should not be lost at a time when anthropogenic global warming continues unabated, despite so much hype by the G20 leaders at their London meeting in early April 2009. Climatic ‘flips’ can go either way.

 See also: Documenting the Palaeogene transition from ‘hothouse’ to ‘icehouse’ in EPN for August 2005, and Magmatic link to the Palaeocene-Eocene warming in EPN for July 2007

Flirting with hand axes

Published on by zooks777Leave a comment

A biface, Acheulean hand axe is more than object of beauty produced by exquisite skill, this industrial genre was invented by African Homo ergaster around 1.6 Ma ago, became a central feature of Palaeolithic archaeology, and lasted until the last few hundred thousand years. Nobody doubts that production of these objects implies a brain that fashioned able to visualise a complex shape within a shapeless lump of rock and to devise a way of achieving it. Moreover, its longevity spanning several species of Homo to our own shows that skills were efficiently passed down through hundreds of thousand generations: possible evidence for linguistic skills in the makers and teachers. But what was it for? Experts have been at a loss to agree on a function: too heavy for hafting to a spear; more awkward for cutting than earlier Oldowan pebble fragments; produced with careful three-dimensional symmetry when a hand tool needs none; time consuming to make yet often found in great abundance and apparently hardly used. One idea is that they were in fact for throwing, in the manner of a discus, yet broken biface axes are rare. A more appealing hypothesis is that they were made for ‘show’ as an element in human sexual selection (Kohn, M. & Mithen, S. 1999. Hand axes: products of sexual selection? Antiquity, v. 73, p. 518-526). Kohn and Mithen argued that the primary function of hand axes was to advertise a maker’s “good genes”: an indicator of the knap­per’s geographic knowledge of suitable resources; his ability to execute a plan; his dexterity and patience; and his so­cial awareness. Those are all attractive qualities in a potential mate. They also suggested that the axes’ often near-pristine quality and occurrence in great numbers at some sites indicate that once their purpose was served, they were thrown away: ‘That man is so cool, he must be good at surviving’. Ten years after Kohn and Mithen first mooted the hypothesis it has come under criticism by April Nowell and Melanie Lee Chang, of the universities of Victoria, Canada and Oregon USA, respectively  (Nowell, A. & Chang M.L. 2009.The case against sexual selection as an explanation of handaxe morphology. Paleoanthropology, v. 2009, p. 77-88).

The critique begins by examining Kohn and Mithen’s interest in symmetry as an element in attractiveness, that Nowell and Chang concede, but consider to have arisen not in a sexual context but in development of vision, despite vision being an evolutionary ‘given’ vastly older than hominins. After a discussion of how fully modern human females base their sexual choices on non-physical attributes of potential mates, such as “niceness,” intelligence, sense of humour, compatibility, willingness to work hard and evidence that the partner in question is attracted to them, Nowell and Chang examine available archaeological evidence. Much of this concerns the ‘absence of evidence’. For instance, there is no evidence to suggest that females did not make hand axes and living females in gatherer-hunter societies do make tools. Other criticisms include: the absence of hand axes from Asia until migration there by H. sapiens [but the biface axe had not been invented when H. ergaster migrated there from Africa around 1.8 Ma]; not all biface axes are symmetrical [but they are nonetheless impressive]; and axes in large numbers generally occur where prey has been butchered, as at Boxgrove, and may have accumulated by hundreds of years of use and loss at such sites by seasonal hunting. The most serious criticism is that some hand axes do show minute patterns that indicate that they were used; although most axes have never been examined for wear patterns. My own conclusion is that the critique is based on absence of evidence for biface axes as ritual objects in sexual selection, but that is not evidence of absence, and I wonder if the 10 years taken to bring together contrary evidence has a bit to do with casting doubt on a not quite ‘PC’ idea. There are many intriguing facets of the fossil and archaeological records of hominins, none more so than those which may have a cultural connotation, like ochre caches (see Deeper roots of culture in EPN of March 2009) and the tear-shaped Acheulean axe. For most we may never know their true context, but can be sure that any curiosity and imagination we apply are reflections of imaginative and curious forebears.

Homo erectus in a cold climate

The famous Zhoukoudian Cave where Peking Man, now known to have been Homo erectus, was first found in 1929 is a lugubrious place. It seems the hominin fossil remains of at least 40 individuals were dragged there and eaten, hopefully by predators. They are by no means the oldest Asian hominins at less than 1 Ma, and their ancestors, probably African H. ergaster, migrated that far around 1.6 to 1.8 Ma ago. Until this year, decent ages from Zhoukoudian were a problem: the errors on estimates of around 500 ka were too large (the likely time lies in a ‘datability gap’ between the capabilities of Ar-Ar and 14C dating methods) to see if the hominins were living at such a high latitude (40ºN) in warm or cold conditions. The latter would be of great interest as it suggests both the use of fire and clothing, and probably adaptation to cooked tubers. In fact, even in the current interglacial episode Beijing gets mighty cold in winter. However, cosmic-ray bombardment can produce unstable isotopes that are suited to dating in that gap, provided materials have been exposed to them. The fossil-containing sediments in Zhoukoudian Cave contain quartz that was exposed at the surface and washed in at the same time as H. erectus individuals were dragged in. Decay of cosmogenic 26Al to 10Be and measurement of parent and daughter isotopes in quartz grains have yielded ages of 770±80 ka, somewhat older than earlier estimates (Shen, G. et al. 2009. Age of Zhoukoudian Homo erectus determined with 26Al/10Be dating. Nature, v. 458, p. 198-200). This age roughly correlates with layers in the western Chinese windblown loess deposits that were deposited during the dry conditions of a minor glacial episode.

See also: Ciochon, R.L. & Bettis, E.A. 2009. Asian Homo erectus converges in time. Nature, v. 458, p.153-154. Gibbo0ns, A. 2009. Ice age no barrier to ‘Peking Man’. Science, v.  323, p. 1419.

 

Walking with the ancestors

From time to time the most evocative hominin trace fossils come to light, such as the Australopithecus afarensis footprints fount by Mary Leakey at Laetoli in Tanzania. A recent one is of footprints of a probable H. ergaster dating back to 1.5 Ma near Lake Turkana in Kenya, not far from the site of the famous ‘Turkana Boy’ skeleton of the same species (Bennett, M.R. and 11 others 2009. Early hominin foot morphology based on 1.5-million-year old footprints from Ileret, Kenya. Science, v. 323, p. 1197-1201). Not only does the trackway reveal details of flesh, skin and bones of the feet, but careful analysis of 3-D scans of the prints, in the context of the mechanical properties of the material walked upon, allows the authors to show that the person who left them moved in essentially the same way as do we when walking through soft mud. They are distinctly different from the Laetoli prints, showing arches and very distinct big toes that are so necessary for ‘springiness’ and bipedal balance respectively.

See also: Crompton, R.W. & Pataky, T.C. 2009. Stepping out. Science, v. 323, p. 1174-1175.

The Great Bend of the Pacific ocean floor

Published on by zooks7771 Comment

Ocean island chains are trackways of moving lithospheric plates relative to the underlying mantle. Mantle hotspots act in a similar manner to a candle that would burn a line in a sheet of paper were one to be passed over it. The largest, most coherent and best studied ocean island chain is that of the Hawaiian Islands and the Emperor Seamounts  in the NW Pacific. The volcanoes that built the chain range in age continuously from Late Cretaceous (81 Ma) at the northern tip of the Emperor Seamounts where they touch the Kamchatka Peninsula to the present in the Big Island of Hawai’i itself. So far, so good for the hotspot-track hypothesis. But the chain is bent into a WNW segment (Hawaii) and one that trends NNW (Emperor). That might seem to be superb evidence that the direction of West Pacific sea-floor spreading underwent a sudden, 60º change around 47 Ma (the age of the Diakakuji seamount at the apex of the bend). However, measurements in 2001 of palaeomagnetic latitude in sea-floor cores along the chain revealed clear palaeomagnetic evidence that the Hawaiian hot spot has not always been fixed relative to moving lithospheric plates.  From Late Cretaceous to Late Eocene times the hotspot seems to have been was shifting southwards relative to the north magnetic pole at a rate comparable with that of sea-floor spreading, and then became stationary to explain the 60° bend in the chain (See American Geophysical Union 2001 Fall Meeting in EPN for January 2002).

Further work has been done since 2001, and a review of the huge oddity that bucks John Tuzo Wilson’s 1963 theory of hotspots fixed in space and time is timely (Tarduno, J. et al. 2009. The bent Hawaiian-Emperor hotspot track: inheriting the mantle wind. Science, v. 324, p. 50-53). Data have moved on to suggest that the hotspot is indeed the head of narrow mantle plume originating deep down, perhaps even near the core – mantle boundary (CMB). But could such a massive structure change it’s behaviour so that its head would move? Some have suggested the development of a propagating crack in the Pacific lithosphere and then its closure, but no evidence points unerringly that way. After considering a range of possible mechanisms, the authors suggest that the great bend records past changes in mantle flow beneath the West Pacific, so that the plume would itself have bent in the vertical dimension. Seismic tomography has revealed apparently low-angled zones of hot, low-velocity mantle, such as one that may (or may not) connect with the Afar plume beneath the triple junction of the East African Rift, the Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden after rising from the CMB south of Cape Town. They are tantalising results, because the resolution is simply not good enough to be sure. It needs an order of magnitude better tomographic resolution of mantle features to truly make more headway.

‘Clean’ coal and soda pop

Published on by zooks777Leave a comment

An option much touted as a means of having our cake (power stations fired by fossil fuels, especially coal) and eating it (escaping runaway global warming while enjoying a high-energy lifestyle) is extracting carbon dioxide from flue gases, or even the atmosphere itself, and safely disposing of it in long-term storage. Carbon capture and storage (CCS) is not a well-tried technology. Yet some authorities claim it is at the least a means of ‘tiding-over’ an economy that depends to such a degree on fossil carbon burning as an energy source that it seems unlikely that alternative, carbon-neutral sources can be deployed in time to stave off increasingly awful and plausible climate and thereby social scenarios. There are others who are convinced that CCS is merely an excuse to continue with ‘business as usual’, and therefore fraught with dangers. Whichever, there are elements of CCS that do concern geoscientists, such as where should it be stored and in what form. Leaving aside some of the geological issues of storage, such as depleted natural petroleum fields or deep aquifers, what happens to CO2 at depth? There are five possibilities: it remains as a gas; under high pressure it may take on liquid form (CO2 can exist only as gas or ‘dry ice’ at atmospheric pressure); it reacts with the rock itself to form some kind of carbonate; under moderate pressure and low temperature it may combine with water to form a gas-hydrate ‘ice’, as does methane; or it may dissolve in water under high pressure.

The ideal form for long-term storage would be in the form of solid carbonate, but that demands bicarbonate ions combining with calcium, magnesium or perhaps sodium ions. One possibility is through dissolution in highly saline groundwater. The chemical reactions are not complex, but depend on the solubility of carbonates being exceeded because of massive increases in bicarbonate concentrations. However, experiments have had little success. Another means of solid storage is by the combination of atmospheric CO2 with calcium hydroxide to form calcium carbonate, which is what happens when lime plaster slowly ‘cures’. The downside is that the only means of making Ca(OH)2 is by kilning limestone: no free lunch there. To cut a long story short, a view is emerging that CO2 pumped, in whatever form, into wet rock will end up dissolving in groundwater, to form vast quantities of ‘sparkling’ water, or ‘soda pop’ (Gilfillan, S.M.V. and 10 others 2009. Solubility trapping in formation water as dominant CO2 sink in natural gas fields. Nature, v. 458, p. 614-618). The British, Canadian, US and Chinese team investigated nine natural gas fields in which CO2 is present as well as petroleum gas, using noble gases and carbon isotopes as tracers of the chemical fate of the natural CO2 as the reservoir rocks filled with oil and natural gas during maturation. They discovered that the bulk of CO2 ended up dissolving to form a weakly acidic water under pressure. This is a recipe for filling huge analogies of soda siphons. They did discover that some CO2 ended up as solid carbonate, but no more than 15%. As those who add Perrier or Volvic to their Scotch should know, carbonated springs are not unknown. Consequently, CCS that uses confined aquifers poses the danger of eventual leakage, whether CO2 is stored as gas, liquid or in solution. Petroleum geologists often claim that no trap is leak proof, and extensive areas of gas leakage are known over most oil fields; they are an important sign for explorationists, if they can be detected. The other issue is that fans of CCS set much store in re-use of depleted commercial oil and gas fields for sequestration. Such fields have already been depressurised, and nobody knows whether or not they were leaky to gas and water.

See also: Aeschbach-Hertig, W. 2009. Clean coal and sparkling water. Nature, v. 458, p. 583-4.